Scents
are InTOXICating
by
Sue Williams
I
bank at a credit union and for over a year we have been at war.
Not because of any discrepancy in my account, but because of the
overwhelming, breathtaking fragrance inside. This odor permeates
even the drive-up tubes and this toxic air comes inside the vehicle
whenever I open one to retrieve my deposit slip. Those folks at
the credit union think I am a bit emotionally labile and you can
be sure I am when it comes to the ability to breathe.
The
American Lung Association published an article in ìAsthma
Magazineî, Wheezing at Work - The Office Can Be Home To
An Assortment of Asthma Triggers. This article states ì70%
of people with asthma experience a worsening of symptoms when
exposed to allergens and irritants. ..... but many asthma triggers
can be found in offices as well. Some common asthma triggers in
the office setting include: ..... perfumes and colognes (from
coworkers) ....î
We
have to conclude from this article that the American Lung Association
recognizes chemicals and fragrances to be asthma triggers.
Perfume
is made of toxic chemicals that can injure your health. The National
Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes
of Healthís listing of ìCommon Indoor Air Pollutantsî
is proof enough for me that our government also recognizes that
fragrances are pollutants. http://www.niehs.nih.gov/external/faq/indoor.htm
The
20 most common chemicals found in 31 fragrance products can be
found on the website, http://users.lmi.net/~wilworks/ehn20.htm.
This site also lists the effects these chemicals have on our central
nervous systems, lungs, skin, eyes, etc. Not pretty.
In
the article Smelling Good But Feeling Bad - Synthetic Perfumes,
Colognes and Scents Are Turning Up Noses, by Damon Franz and Holly
Prall, http://allergies.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ourlittleplace.com%2Fperfume.html
-- the writers cite the Louisiana State Medical Centerís
finding that one out of every five asthmatics experiences an attack
as a result of exposure to perfume. Since the American Lung Association
states that asthma attacks afflict about 14.6 million Americans
and kill an estimated 5,000 each year, that equates to an estimated
2.92 million asthmatics whose asthma attacks are a result of exposure
to perfume.
Acute
severe reactions may be associated with hypersensitivity, a condition
of hyperreactive airways that effects 10-20% of the U.S. population,
according to the EPA. Concentrations of VOCs measured indoors
are usually far below occupational threshold limit values (TLVs),
the point above which health effects may occur, but they may at
times, exceed human odor thresholds, or the point at which an
odor becomes offensive.
Fragrance
chemicals are volatile by nature. This means some of each fragranced
product used ends up in the air. The result is a complex mixture
of chemicals that is constantly changing. The Environmental Health
Center, A Division of the National Safety Council, lists Volatile
Organic Compounds (VOCs) as one of the major air pollutants.
Dozens
of different VOCs have been measured in indoor air from a variety
of sources including building products, cleaning agents, paints
and finishes, fragrances and hair sprays, office equipment such
as copiers and printers, and infiltration of outdoor air. Using
air cleaners or filtration devices proves ineffective.
The
issue of fragrances in the workplace can be addressed from several
perspectives. Fragrances add to indoor air pollution and are a
general health concern whether a person is fragrance sensitive
or not. The chemicals in perfumes, colognes, and deodorants worn
by employees add to the chemical mixtures in indoor air, as do
fragrances in cleaning products.
Simply
touching a surface that someone else with fragrance on their hands
has touched can cause allergic reactions. Since fragrance chemicals
are absorbed through the skin, they can and do affect other organs
of the body.
A
person that is fragrance sensitive is often put into a ìno
winî situation.
It
is not as simple as it sounds to avoid exposure to fragrance chemicals.
Even when purchasing fragrance free materials, there is no assurance
the product will not contain fragrance chemicals. Fragrance chemicals
can be added to a product to cover or mask the odor of other chemicals
in the product. This is often listed on the label with other ingredients
as "masking fragrance". It is not required by law to
be put on the label and not all manufacturers list the masking
fragrances.
Avoidance
of exposure to other's fragranced products is even more difficult.
By design, fragrances get into the air and linger a long time.
They settle and stick to hair, clothes, furniture, and furnishings.
People often spray their clothes with fragrance so what ever their
clothes touch have some of the fragrance materials on it. It is
impossible to be in an environment where fragranced products are
used and not be exposed. The minute we breathe in, whatever chemical
is in the air is in our bloodstream. This is because our lungs
are designed to extract air (oxygen) and place it in our blood.
If the air is polluted with toxic chemicals, so are our bodies.
No
agency regulates the fragrance industry. According to John Baily,
Phd, Director, Colors and Cosmetics, FDA, "The fragrance
and cosmetic industry is the least-regulated industry. There is
no pre-clearing of chemicals with any agency."
The
FDA has suggested the best method "to protect sufferers from
odor sensitivities might be to curtail odor exposures under specific
circumstances through local or state regulatory action."
Some
progress in this respect has been made:
* The federal Access Board adopted a ìfragrance-freeî
meeting policy.
* Postal Regulations, Domestic Mail Manual, 124.395 Fragrance
Advertising Samples (39 USC 3001 (g) April 1990), states that
fragrance strips for mailing "cannot be activated except
by opening a glued flap or binder or by removing an overlying
ply of paper."
* California AB 2709 (as of January 1, 1992) states that "fragrances
contained in any newspaper, magazine, or other periodically-printed
material, published or offered for sale, or contained in any advertisement
- mailed or otherwise distributed - shall be enclosed in a sealant
sufficient to protect a consumer from inadvertent exposure to
the cosmetic - including, but not limited to, the inadvertent
inhalation thereof."
* The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1992 guarantees access
to disabled to institutions, such as government agencies, libraries,
doctor's offices, retail stores, and many others.
There
are no such ordinances, local or state, that I know of in my area.
It is time.
Fragrances
are a "barrier to access" for the MCS/EI disabled, since
breathing is affected.
Breathing is a "major life activity" as defined by the
ADA. Fragrance bans meet the "reasonable accommodation"
clause of the ADA, since elimination and substitution are not
expensive.
Inform
the US Access Board (http://www.access-board.gov/) when you are
denied access due to fragrances. Air is part of every building
and conveyance, and it cannot be "shaken out."
We
must all work toward better indoor air quality using all the legal
and ethical means available to us. In the meantime, if you have
problems with chemical sensitivity, help is available. Tipu Sultan,
MD, has been practicing Environmental Medicine in the St. Louis
area since 1979. Dr. Sultan can help the chemically sensitive
individual through support of the immune system. The chemically
sensitive have a tough row to hoe, and in most cases they can
improve. Dr. Sultan is head of the Environmental Health and Allergy
Center ñ St. Louis, located at 11585 W. Florissant Ave.,
Florissant, MO, and can be reached by calling 314-921-5600.
|